Photo: Craig Sjodin/ABC/Getty

BACHELOR IN PARADISE - 814 Engagements are right around the corner in Paradise, but just as the seemingly stable remaining couples are feeling the romance, a series of surprise visits shake things up on the beach. First up, Bachelorettes Gabby and Rachel have arrived, ready to spill all the tea on their former flames to their new ladies. Then, Becca and Thomas arrive to share an exciting announcement the beach is getting its first-ever Sadie Hawkins dance! Will the 90s-themed evening be a fun night out for the tropical lovebirds or is heartbreak on the horizon? Find out on Bachelor in Paradise, TUESDAY, NOV. 15 (8:00-10:00 p.m. EST), on ABC. (Craig Sjodin/ABC via Getty Images) BECCA KUFRIN, THOMAS JACOBS

The reality star, 33, and her fiancé, 30, made their big pregnancy announcement on their respective Instagram accounts Wednesday. Posing with their two canine furbabies and a strip of ultrasound photos, the couple revealed that they will be adding a fifth member to the clan this fall.

Becca Kufrin/Instagram

https://www.instagram.com/p/Crg59tvgDYz/?hl=en Party of 5 coming September 2023. Little Bebe, we can’t wait to meet you, hold you, and watch you grow. We already love you to the moon and back - mom & dad #pregnanyannouncement #bebe #momanddad #pregnantnotpasta

Kufrin added the humorous hashtag: “#pregnantnotpasta” to the post, as well.

The pregnancy marks the first (human) child for both Kufrin and Jacobs.

https://www.instagram.com/p/Crg59tvgDYz/?hl=en Party of 5 coming September 2023. Little Bebe, we can’t wait to meet you, hold you, and watch you grow. We already love you to the moon and back - mom & dad #pregnanyannouncement #bebe #momanddad #pregnantnotpasta

The two got engaged in the spring of 2022, marking Kufrin’s third engagement. She first got engaged toArie Luyendyk Jr.onThe Bachelor, then accepted a proposal fromGarrett Yrigoyenon her own season ofThe Bachelorette.

Kufrin and Jacobs' engagement garnered extra attention because ofthe role reversal: Kufrin was the one who proposed to Jacobs. However, in October 2022, the couple got engaged againafter Jacobs planned his own proposal.

Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free daily newsletterto stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

“The thought, care and excitement that he put behind his proposal meant the world to me. He prepped for weeks to get it ready,” Kufrin told PEOPLE at the time.

source: people.com