Fitbit is such a tease . In October , the company announcedthree new fittingness trackersjust in meter for the vacation gift - giving season — but decided not to ship two of them till 2015 . Well , having now drop sentence with the Charge , Charge HR , andSurge , we believe the Charge HR is the one you want .
The $ 150 Fitbit tutelage HR does n’t look like much , and that ’s generally a upright thing . It ’s a nondescript isthmus ( I test the fateful one ) you wear on your wrist 24 hour a Clarence Shepard Day Jr. . While it unquestionably does n’t front fancy or expensive , it ’s pernicious enough that it ’ll go with somewhat much anything you have on . Unless you get the hopeful orange version , in which case your style problems likely extend far beyond the kingdom of wearable tech .
Superficially , it ’s a dead ringer for the normal Charge and the ill - fated Fitbit Force , which was come back when a few hoi polloi complained of skin irritation . Which mean it ’s basically just a rubber circle with a small light-emitting diode screen and a single clitoris on the side . The display is minuscule and thin ( like the bottom third cut off a postage seal ) , and it stays off unless you push the button to wake it up . It also scuffs fairly well . When it ’s unobjectionable , it ’s bright enough to take in sunlight , but I ’m already get a little trouble due to early wear and tear .
Physically , there are really only two real divergence between the Charge and the Charge hour . The Charge has a half - assed grip chemical mechanism that made the circle absolutely refuse to abide on my wrist joint when I reached into a handbag or contract a jacket on or off . It ’s kind of a miracle that I did n’t lose it . The Charge HR , on the other hand , has a standard watch strap with a settlement that works like a belt buckle , or any Casio watch you don as a kid . It ’s a morsel less well-situated ( especially when typing ) but I got used to it after a couple days , and it ’s some 100 time more secure . I ’ll take the trade - off .
The most meaning difference between the two Charges , though , is the Charge HR ’s namesake ticker rate monitor . Flip ’em over and take a peep at their underbellies , and you ’ll see the Charge 60 minutes has a little bit of a hump . That ’s what let it keep tabs on your pulse 24/7 . That hump beseech into your skin so you do n’t call for to ratchet down the set too tightly . ( Our current pet fittingness admonisher , the Basis Peak , employs the same trick ) .
Basis Peak Review : The Best Activity Tracker Yet
Why is this important ? Well , most physical fitness tracker out there are really just laud pedometers . They count your steps , how much meter you spend being “ fighting , ” and better ones even have an altimeter to gauge how many level you ’ve climbed . Still , that ’s a pretty abstractionist picture of your wellness . Think about it : you might send your heart racing while snowboarding or ride a cycle , but because the relate motion do n’t look like step they wo n’t count . Heart charge per unit information , on the other hand , gives you a much effective idea of how hard your heart has been working , which gives you a much clearer picture of your genuine caloric suntan . It ’s about as ripe an idea as you’re able to get in your day - to - day life , really .
The just news is that I ’ve found the Charge hour to be very accurate . I tick off the pedometer by walking a set amount of steps and delay the Fitbit ’s read-out before and after . One prison term I started at 7,460 stairs , then I walk , number out 1,000 step as cautiously as I could . At the end , the Fitbit showed 8,455 . Just five off ! Really impressive . With the HRM , I train my pulse rate ( or had a friend take it ) and then insure the display . In closely every test the Charge HR was within two to four musical rhythm per minute , which is a very low gross profit margin of error .
The Charge HR is also very well-fixed to use . You basically just pair it with your iPhone or Android phone , enroll some basic data about yourself into the Fitbit app , and then you just wear the thing . It also comes with a wireless USB dongle if you do n’t have a smartphone and would rather just pair it with your computer . From there all you really want to do is wear the affair . Fitbit claims the Charge hour will last “ up to five days ” on a fully charged battery , but I actually found that it did a little good than that — I got almost six full days ( Sunday night through Saturday eve ) . For a small twist that ’s constantly monitor your beat , that ’s really good . The Basis Peak only gets about four day on a accusation .
Want to see your data ? Just entreat the push on the band to cycle through . In order , you’re able to see the fourth dimension of twenty-four hours , number of steps , current centre rate , estimated mi walked , estimate Calorie cauterise , and floors climbed ( 10 feet of elevation gained = one story ) . Holding down the push take up a stopwatch , if you care . Sleep tracking is now automatic ( thank the paradise ) , so you never have to remember to wrench sopor mode on when you ’re groggily going to sleep or remember to turn it off when you ’re ( even more groggily ) waking up .
The biggest Cinderella story may be Fitbit ’s app . It used to be clunky , slimy , buggy , and highly unintuitive . It is now hands - down the cleanest , easy fitness tracker app out there . Jawbone ’s excellent UP app actually looks confusing by comparison . The Fitbit app render you all the twenty-four hour period ’s most important info on a individual page . It ’s a immediate , at - a - glance view that tell apart you everything : gradation , kilocalorie , floors , medium heart pace , nap , everything . If you desire more info on any of those thing , you just tap it , and it ’ll plunk deeply . It even has handy small explainers in each category to avail you infer what your metric function think . you’re able to also apply it to set silent alarm to wake you up in the morning without agitate your bedmate .
There are some advance feature , too , like food logging . The app now admit an easy to use intellectual nourishment lumber cover that have you search for items and scan food for thought barcodes too . It ’s right smart wanton to use than Jawbone ’s version , and it ’s pretty and clean than the democratic MyFitnessPal . ( If you ’re examine to lose weight unit , monitoring your kilocalorie in and your calories out is the best elbow room to do it — sorry , cult diet . )
The app also leverages your telephone set ’s build up - in GPS , so you may track run and get coaching while you exercise . Personally , I still favour to utilise standalone apps like Runkeeper or Runtastic , but since those both divvy up data with Fitbit ’s app , it does n’t really weigh .
This would be a undecomposed place to tattle aboutthe Fitbit Surgefor a sec . The Surge is essentially a crossbreed between the Charge HR and a smartwatch . ( At least I think that ’s the idea . ) It has all the same features as the Charge hour , but it ’s large and it has more robust apprisal . The Charge HR can vibrate and display the name of incoming caller , but the Surge can display incoming text edition , too . The Surge also has a work up - in GPS , so you may get across your outside runs , hikes , and wheel drive without call for to have a headphone with you . Personally , I think it ’s mostly a good idea to have your phone with you anyway , plus I like listening to music while I run , so I do n’t think the Surge is worth the add bulk or the additional $ 100 that it cost . That suppose , you should still readour full Fitbit Surge reassessment , write by the esteemed Mr. Eric Limer .
https://gizmodo.com/fitbit-surge-review-if-only-this-was-actually-a-smartw-1683726165
Oh , speak of workout , Fitbit warn that if you ’re engage in an action that ask a net ton of subdivision motility ( like boxing , or some P90X workout ) there may be points where the heart rate monitoring will cut out . It claims , though , that these fugitive optical aberration do n’t drive in up the overall data point , as it ’ll extrapolate from the menses where it ’s getting good affection rate information and give you an average heart rate for that period . It ’s not a perfect root , but none of these wrist - mounted HRMs fair any better . If you desire the infrangible best data point for your physical exercise , bureau straps are commonly still the most precise ( though they ’re pesky to apply ) , and the coming category of HRM earbuds are actually very exact as well .
One potential dealbreaker : The Fitbit Charge HR is not rainproof . It ’s “ swither , rain , and splashproof , ” but it is not swim - trial impression or shower test copy . This is obtuse . I mean , the good news is that I by chance forgot about it and fag it in the rain shower every solar day and it seems to be fine , but it sucks that you ca n’t float with it . It ’s a lack opportunity .
My only other existent complaint about the Charge HR is that there ’s a teeny - diminutive groove between where the screen ends and the gum elastic wrist - strap start out , and that gap is just big enough to collect some unsightly ooze . Somehow I got some livid gunk in mine . What is that ? How did I get there ? I do n’t have sex , but it ’s really hard to scrape it out . It ’s a little thing , but it makes it seem slimly less polished and/or agiotage than it otherwise would .
Like
It ’s just so bloody simple to use .
squeamish and subtle look , and the screen is in the main easy to read .
Battery life is very full ( almost 6 day ) , and step counting and pump rate monitoring were both highly accurate .
The web - based interface is nice , too , and it integrate with popular workout apps like Runtastic , Runkeeper , Endomondo , Strava , and others .
No Like
The plastic display is easily scuffed which impacts its visibleness and also just makes it look tinny . The small gap around the screen that let soil in do n’t help either .
expend a proprietary charging cable , which I am almost unquestionably going to misplace ( likely tomorrow ) and then I ’ll be make love . Why not microUSB ?
The grasp on the under side of your wrist can be slightly uncomfortable ( but it ’s still better than the non - locking clasp on the unconstipated care ) .
If you may get caller ID notifications then you ’d conceive it could display MS messages , too . Maybe they ’ll add that in an update at some point .
Very dumb that it ’s not waterproof , swimproof , or showerproof .
Should You Buy It?
Yes . You should . If you want a standalone seaworthiness tracker . This is a really , really good physical fitness tracker and it ’s reasonably priced for what it can do . Not only that , it ’s very accurate , it ’s super light to apply , and it ’s not regretful looking . Fitbit really did a good caper with this one , and I would n’t waffle to call it the best Fitbit yet . But is it the well wearable , period ?
We currently have the Basis Peak in our top slot forBest Fitness Tracker . The Peak has a few more capableness , but it ’s also bigger , bulkier , more expensive , and not quite as intuitive . It did , however , just liberate a major software update that brings real smartwatch notifications . I ’m going to retest the Peak before I make the concluding call , but my intestine say that the Charge hour is credibly better for the bulk of you lovely common people . Unless a peck of your activity takes position in the water , because the Basis Peak is actually waterproofed . Down to 165 feet , anyhow .
The Best Fitness Tracker for Every Need
But for me , personally , would I buy the Charge hour ? No , and I ’ll say you why . After test numerous Android Wear devices , I ’m officially on the smartwatch bandwagon , and honestly , I ’m much more likely to keep wearingthe Moto 360 . Yes , despite its mediocre barrage fire lifetime and deficiency of sopor - trailing . It still does the 24/7 heart rate monitoring , which gives me a in effect estimation of my caloric suntan , and it ’s just so damn commodious . I really love not only getting notifications on my watch but also being able to reply to text subject matter , see routine by turn directions while walk , and apply it with my favorite running apps . I really find like it keeps me more booked with the world around me . It ’s kind of a different category , but I only want to wear one gimmick on my wrist , and I ’d rather it be a smartwatch . But yeah , if all you really want is a seaworthiness tracker , then get the Charge hour .
Moto 360 Smartwatch Review : The Best Might Not Be Enough
In casing you ’re enquire if you might be well off with the Fitbit Charge instead of the Charge HR , let me make it very easy for you . There is not a single cause that you should corrupt the commission over the Charge 60 minutes . Not one ! You fall back , so , so much functionality without the heart rate monitor , and you ’re only saving $ 20 . If it were $ 50 cheaper , then maaaaybe , but I ’d still say you should just trim your allowance for an extra few week .
PSA : Fitbit recalled the Forcebecause a small group of the great unwashed complained of some very major skin aggravation . I ’m surely not going to blame the victims , but I ’m also leery of the claims that it was because of the materials used . There was very little evidence for that , but Fitbit did the recall out of an surfeit of caution . The rationality I ’m dubious is because over the last few geezerhood of examination wearables , I ’ve had rashes develop like that , and it ’s ordinarily just because I ’m wearing the band too tightly or because I ’m not require it off , cleaning it , and permit my wrist intimation every once in a while . If you buy any wristable , please , swap articulatio radiocarpea every now and then , strip it off , and let your skin breathe from time to meter . Trust me on this one .
The Charge HR is useable now in four different colors ( black , depressed , plum , and tangerine ) for $ 150 , and as of today , it ’s the seaworthiness tracker I ’d recommend first . [ Fitbit ]
Daily Newsletter
Get the best technical school , scientific discipline , and acculturation news in your inbox daily .
News from the future , delivered to your present .
You May Also Like
